August 13, 2020 By Swapnil Suryawanshi

Topics Gold prices

Even if it proves to be a blip, this week’s volatility in gold may have its uses. For one thing, Tuesday’s steepest single-day price decline in seven years should make bankers in India wary of storing up future trouble by writing risky subprime loans against the country’s most-loved commodity.

Gold has a strong emotive appeal to Indians, who own one-eighth of the metal ever mined. Of late, though, the glitter was beginning to blind the authorities, too. India’s central bank recently raised the loan-to-value limit for advances against gold jewelry to 90% from 75%.

Now that the international price has fallen by 5.7% in one day, and jumped by 1.3% the next, banks will be uneasy with such low margins of safety. Risk aversion will deter them from giving out loans that might not be repaid. However, lenders may still may push borrowers to take up new gold-backed loans to repay delinquent unsecured credit after the central bank’s Covid-19 moratorium on repayment ends this month. If the money doesn’t return, they can at least sit on the commodity.

During the 2008 crisis, American homeowners walked away from underwater mortgages by posting the house keys back to the banks. India’s version of “jingle mail” may also see borrowers put self interest above their cultural affinity for gold, especially if the value of the collateral drops durably.

Blame it on the pandemic. While employment in informal occupations has normalized, the nearly 19 million salaried jobs lost to coronavirus disruption are proving harder to bring back, according to the Center for Monitoring the Indian Economy. Meanwhile, unsecured consumer credit has dried up, forcing the middle class to monetize its rainy-day hoard.

Families weren’t swayed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s previous exhortations to part with their idle 25,000 tons — only 20 tons have been deposited with banks in a five-year-old state program to wean Indians off gold. It’s because they didn’t fall for the chance to earn interest that they had some capacity for self insurance when the country went into a sudden lockdown in March with hardly any fiscal support from the government. If households now lose their gold by borrowing more than they can afford to repay, how will they navigate the next crisis? 

The recent rally that took prices above $2,000 an ounce has prompted other proposals for using gold. One suggestion is for the Indian central bank to transfer its 618 tons of the precious metal at cost to the government and repurchase it at 90% of market value, giving New Delhi the equivalent of $31 billion in freshly minted rupees to repair the economy.

But raiding the Reserve Bank of India’s war chest or asking people to deposit their unaccounted-for gold with the government for a few years — a tax amnesty plan Bloomberg News reported last month — are unnecessary distractions. 

Monetizing gold would be a worthwhile idea if India were facing balance-of-payment difficulties and needed dollars. That isn’t the case: the RBI’s foreign-exchange reserves have soared past $500 billion. Nor is domestic liquidity in short supply. It’s just that even before the pandemic, India was trapped in a multiyear investment funk, which has drained the financial system of its risk-absorbing capital. Tax collections were already faltering, and now they’re cratering. The post-lockdown recovery is giving all indications of being a long slog. So while consumers are looking at gold for survival, the government is viewing it as a tool for revival.

But the central bank doesn’t need accounting gymnastics like parting with its gold and buying it back to support deficit financing. Indonesia’s playbook of openly monetizing budget shortfalls offers a saner alternative, provided India can convince markets that temporary print-and-spend would lift future growth (and tax collections) by plugging a part of the capital crunch. 

Using the central bank’s gold to raise resources is no substitute for bolstering the sovereign’s credibility with investors. Pushing households to do the same won’t bring back their salaried jobs and lost income streams. Now that the yellow metal market has blinked, India will hopefully be able to see its options more clearly.

Andy Mukherjee is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering industrial companies and financial services.

This story has been published from a wire agency feed without modifications to the text. Only the headline has been changed.Subscribe tonewsletters

Click here to read the Mint is now on Telegram. Join Livemint channel in your Telegram and stay updatedTopicsGold pricesClose

  1. GOLD
    52,025 -229 (-0.44%)
    66,965 +212 (+0.32%)
    38,449.29 +79.66 (+0.21%)
  1. NIFTY 50
    11,352.6 +44.20 (+0.39%)
    22,419.25 +155.25 (+0.70%)
    14,550.17 +195.50 (+1.36%)
  1. GOLD
    52,025 -229 (-0.44%)
    66,965 +212 (+0.32%)
    38,449.29 +79.66 (+0.21%)
  1. NIFTY 50
    11,352.6 +44.20 (+0.39%)
Launch of platform for Transparent Taxation – Honoring The Honest, by Prime Minister Narendra Modi

Narendra Modi LIVE Updates: ‘Tax system should be seamless, painless, faceless’

3 min read. 11:42 AM IST

At 11 AM on Thursday, 13th August, the platform for ‘Transparent Taxation – Honoring the Honest’ was launched by Prime Minister Narendra ModiRead Full Story

There is a clear shift towards lowering fixed costs. When gig workers are hired, companies often save on infrastructure and managerial expenses (Photo: Mint)

India Inc embraces the part-time manager

9 min read. 08:15 AM IST

  • In a pandemic-induced rush to cut costs, firms are hiring managers on short-term contracts. Is it here to stay?
  • Of course, all this does not mean that permanent hiring will shrink in a jiffy—80% of the new organized sector jobs could still be long-term in nature

Read Full Story

An ampule of drug Remdesivir. (REUTERS)

Covid-19: India’s cheapest remdesivir version to cost ₹2,800 per vial

2 min read. 10:20 AM IST

  • Zydus is the fifth company to launch a copy of the antiviral in India
  • Gilead has also entered into licensing agreements with Dr.Reddy’s Laboratories Ltd and Syngene International Ltd to make remdesivir for distribution in 127 countries, including India

The Indian government in June banned 59 Chinese apps, including TikTok and WeChat, for threatening its ‘sovereignty and integrity’ after border tensions with China. (REUTERS)

ByteDance in talks with Reliance Industries for investment in TikTok: report

1 min read. 09:15 AM IST

The two companies began conversations late last month and have not reached a deal yet, according to a TechCrunch reportRead Full Story

A file photo of Anand Mahindra. (REUTERS)

Anand Mahindra on Covid-19: Focus on therapeutics, clinical protocols

1 min read. 10:54 AM IST

  • Mahindra said we need to focus on lowering the fatality rate to well below a percent
  • India’s coronavirus tally has touched 23,96,638

The administration also allowed travel of visa holders who are working as public health or healthcare professional,

H-1B visa: Trump makes exception to ban, allows holders to enter US

1 min read. 07:36 AM IST

Trump has relaxed some rules for H-1B visas holders allowing them to enter the United States if they are returning to the same jobs they had prior to the proclamation of the visa ban

SBI Mutual Fund manages total assets worth  ₹3,.65 lakh crore as on June 30.

What stocks SBI Mutual Fund bought and sold last month

1 min read. 10:55 AM IST

SBI Mutual Fund bought 1.80 crore shares of NHPC and over 1 crore shares of City Union Bank in July.

Transition to the BS-VI emission norms, and the resultant price hikes helped improve average selling price and realizations of Ashok Leyland

Steep fall in sales derails Ashok Leyland in Q1; weak recovery clouds outlook

2 min read. 10:25 AM IST

  • Slump in economic activity, initial restrictions on road transport, and unavailability of drivers virtually halted sales of the company post covid-19
  • The big risks to earnings of Ashok Leyland in the near term, which can exert financial pressure on the company, are weak recovery and unusually low sales

A member of Kolkata police adjusts his face mask as he takes part in rehearsal for the Independence Day parade (REUTERS)

India’s coronavirus cases today jump by 67,000, highest daily record

1 min read. 10:29 AM IST

The country’s coronavirus tally touched 23,96,638 including 6,53,622 active cases, 16,95,982 discharged and 47,033 deaths.Read Full Story

Photo: iStock

How work from home may increase tax liability for certain employees

3 min read. 10:38 AM IST

  • House rent allowance (HRA) is one of the major exemptions that employees claim, which helps them bring down their tax liability.

In my fantasy, the schools that are open to expanding their India operations will rise considerably in reputation.

‘Harvard Hyderabad’ or ‘Oxford Kolkata’: Can India attract top universities?

4 min read. 08:38 AM IST

The country has an admirably ambitious plan to attract the world’s top 100 universities.

Metro trains stand parked at a yard, after services were closed for commuters in the wake of coronavirus pandemic, at Timarpur in New Delhi. (PTI)

Delhi Metro: Soon pay with your credit, debit card at AFC gates

2 min read. 09:38 AM IST

  • Delhi Metro has started to upgrade around 600 Automatic Fare collection(AFC) gates
  • Delhi Metro operations have been closed for the public since March 22 in view of the covid-19 pandemic

As per existing law, you cannot file your ITR for more than one year at a time. (MINT_PRINT)

What happens if you don’t file income tax return (ITR): Penalty or even jail

3 min read. 10:00 AM IST

  • Income tax department can launch prosecution against you for non-filing of ITR
  • The tax laws prescribe minimum three years of imprisonment term and which can extent upto seven years

Former president Pranab Mukherjee. Photo: Pradeep Gaur/Mint

My father is still alive, tweets Pranab Mukherjee’s son after rumours galore

1 min read. 09:43 AM IST

‘My Father Shri Pranab Mukherjee is still alive & haemodynamically stable,’ tweeted Abhijit Mukherjee Thursday morning.Read Full Story

Passengers in safety gear at the Bengaluru airport.

Flying to Dubai, Sharjah or Abu Dhabi from India? Check out the new travel rules

3 min read. 09:48 AM IST

  • The ticket booking for flights from UAE to 18 destinations in India from August 16 to 31 has opened
  • Flight operations between India and UAE had been shut for about five months due to the Covid-19 pandemic

Read Full StoryLIVE UPDATESMarket LIVE: HDFC Bank, Kotak Bank lift Sensex by 100 points; Nifty near 11,3506 min read . 11:43 AM ISTDomestic equity benchmark Sensex jumped over 100 points in early trade on Thursday led by gains in index majors TCS, Infosys and HUL amid firm cues from global peers and sustained foreign fund inflowRead Full Story

The hallmark of this road corridor is that it will connect the holy cities of Katra and Amritsar. (PTI)

Jammu to Delhi in 6 hours! Delhi-Katra expressway to be completed by 2023

1 min read. 08:19 AM IST

  • The Katra- Delhi Express Road Corridor will prove to be a path-breaking revolution in promoting industry and investments in the entire region: Dr Jitendra Singh
  • The Katra- Delhi Express Road Corridor is estimated to cost over ₹35,000 crores

Shares of IndiGo parent InterGlobe Aviation closed 10% higher on Wednesday.

Stocks to Watch: InterGlobe Aviation, Aurobindo Pharma, Tata Power, IT companies

2 min read. 07:53 AM IST

  • Private equity firm Westbridge Capital has bought 5.43 million shares or 1.41% stake in InterGlobe Aviation Ltd for ₹559 crore
  • Aurobindo Pharma reported a 22.81% rise in its consolidated net profit to ₹780.68 crore for the quarter ended on 30 June